An interesting conjecture regarding the appearance of the earliest Seyder Tkhines in 1648 is related to the Messianic fervor of the mid-1600’s. In 1648 (5408 in the Hebrew calendar) Jewish kabbalists predicted the first coming of Messiah based on the gematria value of the phrase “end of days” which in Hebrew numerically calculates to 5408. [1] Christian writers including Isaac de la Peyrere (Du Rappel des Juifs) and Pierre de la Fons also predicted 1648 as the date the Christian Messiah would return. When the redemption did not take place in that year, both Jewish kabbalists and Christian millenarians set the next year of salvation as 1666. [2]
In this atmosphere of great Messianic expectation the Seyder Tkhines was published. The title page of the original edition explains the purpose of women reciting the tkhines as a means of gaining entry into the Holy Land through the coming of the Messiah. [3] One of the fast day tkhines includes an extensive prayer composed for the ninth of Av. Devra Kay points out a pertinent parallel between the ninth of Av tkhine and the book of Lamentations (traditionally read during the ninth of Av) in that both express grief as voiced by a female narrator, for in the book of Lamentations the voice of grieving Jerusalem is initially described in the feminine (“her”). [4]
Although the ninth of Av is a time of repentance and mourning regarding the destruction of the first and second Temples, the sages take notice that within this most sad day is contained a seed of hope. Historically (according to Talmud Ta’anit 29a) the fire that destroyed the second Temple began toward evening on the ninth of Av and reached it fullest and most destructive force on the tenth of Av. Yet, the halachah of the ninth of Av begins exceedingly mournful and then eases as the day progresses. Men do not wear tallit or tefillin for shacharit but don the tallit for minchah. One sits on low stools or on the floor until mid-day, at which time one can sit on regular chairs. Work is prohibited (including preparation of food) until mid-day after which the prohibition is lifted. Fasting ends at nightfall and scrupulous individuals who desire to commemorate the total destruction of the Temple on the tenth of Av abstain from eating meat or drinking wine, bathing and laundering until mid-day on the tenth.
In a manner that seems to contradict the logical liturgical order of the day, on the ninth of Av mourning lessens as the historical time the fire and destruction of the Temple is understood to have become heightened. The most extreme grieving takes place during the morning hours becoming less extreme at night and during the following day (when the Temple was actually consumed in flames and burned to the ground). Rebbetzin Tziporah Heller explains this seeming contradiction as incorporating the principle that at the time of greatest destruction and despair, the hope of redemption is born. [5] It is at times when the impossible happens and the greatest disasters take place that one feels an uncanny closeness to G-d and redemption becomes “real” and longed for. From this the rabbis developed the concept that “on Tisha b’Av Mashiach is born”. In this way everything that brings about Mashiach’s coming has the possibility to be “born within us” at this time. [6]
Therefore, the mourning of Tisha b’Av lightens as the historical time of the destruction increases. Because the historic time encompasses the most extensive details of disaster this time also provides the greatest opportunity for the hope of redemption to be realized and the seeds of redemption to be planted. With this in mind some women of the Chabad tradition will begin to scrub floors and clean house after mid-day on the ninth of Av in anticipation of the awaited redemption. [7]
Similar concepts are seen in Yeshua’s teachings regarding the destruction of the Temple and his second coming (Matthew 24:6-25:13, Mark 13:1-37, Luke 21:5-8). In Mark 13:32-37 watchfulness regarding the second coming is likened to a servant who is placed in charge of the home of his master who has taken a long journey to a far away county. The home must be kept in order for the servant does not know when the master will return. If the master’s return is likely of course the servant will make sure that the house is clean.
The three synoptic accounts relate awesome and unbelievable physical changes in the sun, moon, stars, and heavens to occur prior to the Son of Man’s return. In Luke 21:28 Yeshua says:
Yet, upon close reading Yeshua admonishes his disciples to “look up and lift up your heads” “when these things begin to happen”. These things, which Yeshua has been speaking of, begin with the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem, in which “not one stone will be left upon another”.
With this in mind, and with Tisha b’Av understood as a day of great sorrow in which the hope of redemption takes root in reality, I provide the tkhine for the ninth of Av below as translated into English by Devra Kay. May this prayer inspire women to grieve in the uniquely feminine voice through a historic standardized prayer composed with a focus upon redemption and the coming of Messiah.
To be said on the Ninth of Av
Judge of all the world,
Your judgment is right and true,
And without injustice.
You are our true judge forever.
On this day our forefathers,
Those who You led out of Egypt
Through Your servant Moses and Aaron,
Committed many misdeeds.
Again they did not trust in the promise
That You made to our forefathers,
Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob,
So they were not permitted to enter the Holy Land,
Where Your Divine Presence rested
At all times, and where Your Name
Was murmured by Your true servants.
And on that night they all cried,
And their eyes ran like spring water,
And they did not trust in Your assurances.
And when they discovered
Through Your servants Moses and Aaron
That the gift was also to be withheld from their children,
As it happened through Your truth,
They cried many tears on this day.
On this day of Your great splendor,
Both Temples were destroyed and wiped out.
The crown fell to earth,
And we can no longer bring sacrifices
To the offering stool
In honor of Your holiness,
And can no longer go three times a year
To see the beauty of Your Divine Presence.
With our faith and conviction
In the great happiness
With which the Holy Divine Presence
Rested among the cherubim
And spoke with Your children
On the High Holy Days
In the face of great bravery,
Against great wealth,
And against great hope
Everything was burnt in a fire from Heaven,
And they chose crooked ways, not good ones.
And women and children who were gentle and educated
Were taken into captivity,
And the maidens were shamed.
And the young men had to drag
Millstones around their shoulders and necks.
And the chains around their feet made them stumble.
And they craved bread in their hunger,
And had no water to quench their thirst.
There was great and bitter frustration
For all the people,
And for this city,
And all lands,
One city that was above all the others
Suffered great and bitter frustration.
And they called out for mercy
To overturn his hatred.
They called out to their Friend for help,
But no one answered them
Except with evil,
Mocking their Sabbaths and Festivals,
Extinguishing their candles,
And creating darkness.
Lord of all the world,
I stand before You
With a sad heart,
Wailing and weeping,
My eyes run like spring water,
And my heart sighs and cannot be free
Of the memory of the disruption
Of Your children Israel
In the broken city of Yehuda,
And Israel
And their Kingdom.
So they went into captivity,
And the Priests who worshipped in Your House,
And the Levites who sang and beat on all sides
Playing the holy songs,
Are now dispersed,
And all the holy vessels
Have come into unclean hands.
May Your Name be merciful.
My eyes are swollen with great weeping,
And my heart is weak with sighing before You,
And my strength deserts my body,
And the marrow forsakes my bones,
And my limbs are feeble with great lament
For your children Israel.
Who can heal them like you?
You are the One who heals all sickness under Israel,
And you are one Lord over all lords,
Who forgives transgressions
In Your great mercy and compassion.
Turn Your ears toward the cries of Your people Israel,
And open Your eyes and see the plight of Your holy city
Where Your voice called out to them,
And hear how Your children are mocked and shamed among the peoples,
Where their goodness is lost with all their hope.
Give your strength to them,
And let the strength of others come to nothing,
And may they be shamed,
And tremble in awe before the grim severity of Your holiness.
And help us, and gather us together
From all four corners of the world,
From among the peoples,
So we are happy again.
And free us from the pain You gave us,
And remember the covenant with our forefathers.
Let it not be lost to us among the peoples,
And rebuild the holy city again with Your continuity.
As the prophet said:
In honor of You
I wish to receive Your mercy and compassion.
For you forgive the misdeeds of Your people Israel
Out of love
When our eyes and our hearts are faithful to you,
And when we serve You
You are our consolation.
Therefore console us in our unhappiness
And protect us from further sadness,
And send us Your beloved
Who will beg only for the good of Your children Israel.
And on this day, may we celebrate,
And praise Your Name,
And tell of Your great wonder.
And may You save us now
As You saved us from Egypt,
So we may soon rejoice,
In our day.
Amen. [8]
[2] Ibid. p. 35
[3] Ibid. p. 45
[4] Ibid. p. 166
[6] Ibid.
[8] Devra Kay, op. cit. pp. 166-169.